Reasonably Required Is Not “The Doctor Ordered It”

Claims Professional Reviewing Imaging and Case file

I was reviewing a report one of my physicians was providing for one of our clients. The contention was that this individual had significant pathology and wanted treatment for that pathology, which, in the opinion of the physician/author, is clearly long-standing, pre-existing, and completely unrelated comorbidities. It was clear that there was pathology to address, and that this injured individual felt all care suggested as treatment should be covered under workers’ compensation.

What Care Belongs to the Claim?

I had a discussion with several colleagues about the nuances of workers compensation insurance here in the great state of Texas. A sentence came up concerning the Texas statute and what is “reasonably required.” There are very few phrases within the Texas Workers’ Compensation environment that sound simpler than “reasonably required.” As per the statute, “Health care reasonably required” means health care that is clinically appropriate and considered effective for the injured employee’s injury and provided in accordance with best practices consistent with: (A) evidence-based medicine, or, if that evidence is not available, generally accepted standards of medical practice recognized in the medical community. [Texas Labor Code §401.011(22-a)] However, in practice, those two words carry so much of the weight in deciding what, if any, treatment belongs to that compensable injury.

Treating the Whole Person

As a clinician, I was taught that we treat the entire person irrespective of what, if any, insurance they have to cover the expenses. If an individual presented in my clinic, with complaints of low back pain, pain shooting into the lower extremity, plain radiographs showing osteophytes and joint space narrowing, my clinical determination of what is currently going on is far different than commenting on the sequelae of a minor lifting type of event.

Consequently, this becomes an issue as not every treatment or intervention suggested by the treating provider should be approved as “reasonably required” to address the sequelae of the compensable event. However, this also does not mean that an expensive treatment should be denied simply because of the cost.

Findings Must Support the Compensable Injury

The standard that must be applied is whether the actual consequences of the injury is being addressed as opposed to the entirety of all of the pathology identified. This determination starts with the specific mechanism of injury, the initial and subsequent findings on physical examination, and a clear clinical appraisal of the findings noted with any diagnostic imaging study completed.

Was the Condition Aggravated?

At this point, the question becomes aggravation or exacerbation. The argument usually sounds like this: I did not have pain before, I have pain now, so the injury must have made my (fill in the blank) worse. That is a timeline, not a cause. An aggravation claim needs objective evidence of a change. Useful evidence includes prior records showing the condition was already being treated, comparison imaging from before the injury, and examination findings that are new rather than simply newly reported. An MRI taken early can help too. Fluid-sensitive sequences (T2 and STIR) may show bone or soft tissue edema that fits an acute event. That signal is not specific to trauma, though, and it fades with time. Imaging supports the answer.

As noted with the example presented above, the findings on MRI are very real. This individual has significant, long-standing, problematic changes in the spine that are causing significant symptoms. The pain associated with this pathology is very real. However, when noting the reported mechanism of injury, there is no objective medical evidence that these changes are a function of that event.

Going Beyond the Guidelines

Here in Texas, we are quite fortunate that our labor code ties treatment decisions to evidence-based medicine. More specifically, the Division of Workers’ Compensation has adopted the Official Disability Guidelines as a basic treatment parameter. If treatment is to be provided outside these guidelines, a preauthorization protocol is to be completed, and the medical evidence can be independently evaluated. However, to be clear, these are Official Disability Guidelines, (and not official disability carved in stone), and any reasonable presentation of current medical/literature evidence can overcome those published parameters. Care outside the guidelines is not barred. The provider must request preauthorization and document the evidence that supports the exception, which the Official Disability Guidelines addresses in its Appendix D.

The guidelines are a starting point; however, any treatment decision must be tempered by the above noted factors (e.g., mechanism of injury, findings on physical examination, determination of what specific pathology occurred as a result of the compensable event). If a treating provider wished to go outside the noted guidelines, then it would be incumbent upon that individual to provide appropriate citations of the literature supporting why this treatment is warranted. Unless you have all of the appropriate documentation, the standards as established in the statute are simply not met. This would be an opportunity to reach out to the treating provider and ask the provider for the clinical basis for the treatment plan being suggested.

Establishing the Extent of Injury

From the claim file handler perspective, it would be my recommendation prior to proceeding that two separate issues be resolved. The first being extent of injury. It must be firmly established what occurred as a result of this event. The conversation concerning aggravation or exacerbation should be resolved. Therefore, the first group of questions that should be addressed in every claim file would include:

  1. What has been accepted or adjudicated as the accepted compensable injury based on the clinical information present?
  2. Is the pathology being addressed by the requested treatment a function of the injury or has that pathology been established as long-term and pre-existing?
  3. Do the clinical records provide competent, objective and independently confirmable medical evidence to support the need for the treatment as a function of the compensable injury sustained?

Is the Treatment Reasonably Required?

After this determination is established, the next issue would be healthcare reasonably required. As such, one would suggest the following issues be resolved:

  1. Is the proposed treatment following a well-established and evidence-based medicine progression of care?
  2. What specific measurable functional improvements should be expected with any intervention attempted?

 

Often, we see attempts at intervention simply to address ongoing complaints of pain. Again, when I was in active practice, I would see individuals who had complaints of pain all the time. As I have written about extensively in the past, reported complaints of pain is subjective at best. There are different types of pain. And pain is not a diagnosis; it is simply a symptom. Therefore, any intervention cannot rest solely on complaints of pain.

Supporting Claim Decisions

For the claim file handlers out there reading this note, “reasonably required” should not be translated as the Doctor ordered it, so pay it. Moreover, it should not become a situation where the guidelines do not recommend this treatment, so denied that protocol. The best answer for all parties would be to resolve the issue as quickly as possible, communicate the extent of injury and the clinical basis for the determination as well as the implementation of future treatment. This presentation should be made to the injured employee in terms that they can understand and appreciate. You as the claim file handler are not practicing medicine, you are simply applying objective rational thought to what occurred as a result of this identified event. These two words of “reasonably required” should not be the genesis for a five-figure misunderstanding.

Related Post